Discussion about this post

User's avatar
J. P. Langarfel's avatar

The Harding section gets at something I think about constantly: she writes lyrics that all but dare you to decode them, and then the decoding turns out to be beside the point because the voice has already told you what you needed to know. “A husky toughness that belies vulnerability” is the whole trick in six words—the surface and what's under it pulling against each other in the same line. I'd argue the inscrutability isn't a puzzle withheld so much as a third instrument; you're meant to feel the meaning before you can name it. The microphone-placement detail on “I Ate the Most” is a great catch. Filing this record away to sit with.

Rod Stasick 🇨🇦's avatar

What I'm getting from, "Big thick coats on the dogs of people just trying to help..." is that well-meaning people putting enormous protective coats on their dogs is a weird kind of absurdity where nobody is really behaving badly; they're “just trying to help.” The coats may be excessive, unnecessary, or more expressive of the owners’ anxiety than of what the dogs actually need. So you get an idea of care becoming overprotection - help that arrives already wrapped in somebody else’s assumptions. She makes this a personal statement when you hear the other words in the song where you're inclined to think that the dogs occupy her personal position in relationships:

*People care about me, but what they place around me may not be what I need*

or even

*They're helping the creature they imagine, after first dressing it in a form they understand.*

I have a neighbor who makes me feel quite uncomfortable in this way.

Been enjoying this album since discovering it last month. Good, varied instrumentation.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?